When Laughter Can No Longer Be Silenced

By Anthony Borrow, S.J.

Today, I joined more than 100 priests from around the world who are part of the “Priests Against Genocide” network to pray for peace and justice and to raise awareness of the need to resolve the conflict in Palestine with dialogue and diplomacy. Some of the priests had made a pilgrimage to personally experience the realities of life in the Holy Land. They encouraged us to "come and see." We gathered in the Divine Mercy church for a prayer service and then marched outside carrying a shroud upon which we had written the names of the more than 300 Palestinian and Lebanese children who had been killed after the ceasefire. Stepping outside of the comfort of the church, I joined in singing songs of peace and asking God to be my strength to have the courage to live without fear.

Yet, during the march, I declined an invitation to be interviewed. Afterwards, I was asked if I would be willing to write a reflection of my experience of the day. Despite my prayer to be free of fears of being misunderstood, I found myself reluctant. As one of my former history professors once told me, history is not my forte. I'm hesitant to meddle into politics because I’m woefully ignorant of much of the context that leads to longstanding conflicts.

During the morning presentations, there was a video that spoke about how uncomfortable it is to talk about dead children. It is most unpleasant to speak about dead children. Many prefer that we talk about anything other than dead children. And yet, we were gathered to give voice to the hundreds of children who had been killed. As stories were shared, one particular story drew me into remembering my own sister, Ginger (whom I affectionately called ‘Honeybun’). She died when she was six years old of a rare disease that was never diagnosed. Because of her illness, Honeybun never developed the ability to speak. She could laugh when she was happy and would cry when she was sad. One of the things that made her happy was when I would do impromptu puppet shows for her by putting a pair of socks over my hands. I deeply enjoyed making her laugh.

As I marched and prayed, I carried a wooden heart made from the trees in the Holy Land. Carrying the heart reminded me of Honeybun’s Raggedy Ann doll. One detail etched itself into my young mind. On the doll was a heart with the words "I love you". I longed to show my sister how much I loved her. As I walked, she bore witness to her little brother, who after 50 years of living, continues to carry her name and memories with him. Such memories continue to fill my heart with immense tenderness and love.

2-When Laughter Can No Longer Be Silenced By Anthony Borrow SJ


Speaking of dead children is uncomfortable. Yet it can also be healing. As I listened to the stories shared that day, I found myself returning to memories I may at times shy away from remembering. I remember finding my sister’s lifeless body in bed one Saturday morning. I had come to carry her out with me to watch cartoons. As I listened to the story of Hind Rajab, a 5-year-old girl who had been trapped inside a car attacked by Israeli forces, the memory of a little boy reaching out to touch his sister came back. The young girl had managed to call the Red Crescent for help but hours later she and the paramedics who had come toassisther were all found dead. The chilling story reminded me of the shocking cold that struck my hand as I gently touched my sister’s arm in a futile attempt to wake her up.

Deep within me, I am uncomfortable talking about dead children. I am uncomfortable with the suffering being inflicted upon so many people, especially upon the children. And yet, while marching, I find myself continuing to sing and ask for the grace to be moved beyond my discomfort and fears. Each child whose name was written on the shroud had their laughter silenced by violence. The world will never be able to hear the joyful sounds of their songs. Fr. Greg Boyle, the Jesuit who has ministered to gang members in Los Angeles, wrote a book titled "Tattoos of the Heart". Greg Boyle writes about "tattoos of the heart," the marks that relationships leave upon us. Today, the names of these children have been written upon my own heart.

Love moves me to risk criticism and misunderstanding by speaking about the children whose lives have been cut short by violence. I proudly walk with my brother priests, accompanied by several religious sisters and friends who joined me in marching, praying, and carrying the names of these children in our hearts. I hope that our prayers will bring about a change of heart that will be able to end the violence that deprives us of the ability to hear the laughter that has been stolen from us. I wonder, if we really want to stop talking about dead children, then we ought to consider taking action to disarm and stop killing children and their loved ones. In the hope of preventing the silencing of these children’s laughter, we carried their names and stood in front of one of the leading arms manufacturers in Europe. Weapons do not bring peace.

Participating in the march helped me to rediscover myself as a little boy. The boy who stands at his sister’s bedside and tries to wake her up. The boy who longs to see her smile and to hear her laugh. This little boy continues to mourn. Yet he also longs for a world filled with laughter. Prayer did not remove my discomfort. I am still reluctant to share. Yet the support of so many helped me to rediscover the power of a child’s laugh that cannot be silenced by violence. I see my sister smiling. As I choose not to be silent, I hear the silence disappear and can once again hear my sister laugh. Her name, her story, and her incredible impact upon me live in my heart. I pray that the children whose names we carried may joyfully join with my sister in having their names and stories remembered. Such laughter is one of the most effective ways of bringing peace into our hearts and into the world.

1-When Laughter Can No Longer Be Silenced By Anthony Borrow SJ

Cover image credits: The drawing is inspired by a real image of a Palestinian mother mourning her deceased son, Mohammed Zakaria. Credit: Priests Against Genocide

Share this Post:

Related Posts: